10 Best Restaurants in Pompton Lakes (New Jersey) in 2023

There’s nothing quite like the appeal of small-town charm when it comes to dining. Pompton Lakes, located in Passaic County, New Jersey, might not be the first destination that comes to mind when one thinks of culinary hotspots.

However, this quaint town is brimming with a vibrant restaurant scene that will surprise and delight your palate. In this article, we’ll be counting down the top 10 restaurants in Pompton Lakes, providing you with a comprehensive guide of the town’s best, including menus, prices, and how vegan or vegetarian-friendly they are.

10. Cyndia’s

First on our list is Cyndia’s, an idyllic spot renowned for its brunch offerings. This quaint cafe serves up delicious dishes that pay homage to classic American comfort food. However, their menu boasts some exciting twists on the traditional.

You can savor their all-day breakfast items, like the Caprese Avocado Toast for $12 or the Cyndia’s Corned Beef Hash for $14. For lunch, their Veggie Burger, priced at $13, is a hit among plant-based diners, offering a hearty meal without the meat. Besides these, they offer a range of sandwiches, salads, and wraps. Cyndia’s is also known for its delightful desserts, particularly its decadent ‘Brownie a la Mode’ at $8.

This eatery is vegetarian-friendly with several dishes that can cater to this dietary requirement. However, their vegan options are somewhat limited.

9. The Bayou

The Bayou brings a slice of Southern cooking to Pompton Lakes with its delicious Cajun and Creole-inspired menu. Here, you can experience the rich, flavorful dishes that epitomize southern hospitality, right in New Jersey.

Their standout dishes include the Louisiana Crawfish Étouffée, a steal at $18.95, and their famous Jambalaya at $21.95. Vegetarian diners can enjoy the Vegetarian Po’ Boy, a delightful sandwich filled with seasonal vegetables for $12.95.

While The Bayou does have vegetarian options, it’s worth noting that the menu heavily features seafood and meat, so options may be limited for vegan diners.

8. Moneti’s Pizzeria

Pompton Lakes wouldn’t be a true New Jersey town without an authentic pizzeria, and Moneti’s certainly fits the bill. This family-run establishment prides itself on its delectable, crispy, thin-crust pizzas that come in a variety of enticing flavors.

Pizza prices range from $13 for a basic Margherita to $18 for specialty options like the ‘Bruschetta’ or the ‘Hawaiian BBQ Chicken’. The pizzeria also serves mouth-watering pasta dishes and salads. Their Penne Vodka at $13.99 is a must-try.

Moneti’s is quite vegetarian-friendly with a variety of veggie toppings and pasta options. However, vegan diners may find their choices more restricted.

7. Thatcher McGhee’s

Thatcher McGhee’s transports you to the Emerald Isle with its Irish pub charm. This lively spot, known for its warm, inviting atmosphere, serves up some authentic Irish grub alongside a broad selection of beers and ales.

You can enjoy hearty dishes like Shepherd’s Pie for $16 or Bangers and Mash for $15. However, they also offer American pub staples like burgers and sandwiches. Vegetarian options are not abundant but include a Portobello Sandwich for $12 and a Veggie Burger for $11.

The establishment’s vegan options are unfortunately sparse, so vegan patrons may need to request customizations.

6. Frank’s Pizza

Yet another testament to the New Jersey pizza scene, Frank’s Pizza serves some of the most delicious slices in Pompton Lakes. Beyond their pizza, they offer a wide range of Italian dishes, from pasta to subs to seafood.

Their pizza range is expansive, with a basic cheese pizza at $11.50 and specialty pies like the ‘Buffalo Chicken Pizza’ or ‘Veggie Pizza’ at $16.75. Pasta lovers can enjoy dishes like ‘Fettuccini Alfredo’ or ‘Linguini with Clam Sauce’ for $14.95.

Frank’s Pizza is vegetarian-friendly, with a host of vegetable toppings and vegetarian dishes. However, vegan options are limited.

5. Thai Jasmine Cuisine

As the premier Thai restaurant in Pompton Lakes, Thai Jasmine Cuisine offers a delightful array of authentic Thai dishes. Known for its cozy atmosphere and friendly staff, this restaurant will make you feel as if you’ve traveled to the heart of Thailand.

Their menu includes classics like ‘Pad Thai’ for $13.95 and ‘Green Curry’ for $14.95. They also offer an array of vegan-friendly dishes such as ‘Tofu Satay’ for $7.95 and ‘Papaya Salad’ for $8.95.

This restaurant is both vegetarian and vegan-friendly, making it a great choice for those with these dietary preferences.

4. Mario’s Pizzeria

No list of Pompton Lakes restaurants would be complete without a mention of Mario’s Pizzeria. This longtime local favorite has been serving up mouthwatering slices for decades. Beyond pizza, their menu spans various Italian classics, from hearty subs to pasta to appetizers.

Prices for their pizzas range from $10.50 for a plain pie to $17.50 for their ‘Special Pizza’, topped with a bit of everything. A classic ‘Spaghetti with Marinara Sauce’ is priced at $10.50.

Mario’s Pizzeria is quite vegetarian-friendly, offering a range of vegetable toppings and meat-free dishes. Vegan options, as with many pizzerias, are more limited.

3. Oceanos Restaurant

For those seeking a fine dining experience in Pompton Lakes, Oceanos Restaurant should be at the top of your list. This upscale eatery offers an extensive seafood-focused menu that’s sure to impress.

Standout dishes include ‘Chilean Sea Bass’ at market price and ‘Pan Roasted Diver Scallops’ for $34. They also offer an impressive ‘Vegetable Paella’ for $24, making this a somewhat vegetarian-friendly option.

While the focus is on seafood and meats, vegetarian dishes are available. Vegan options, however, may require some customization.

2. Selenita Restaurant

Selenita Restaurant brings the bold, vibrant flavors of Mexican cuisine to Pompton Lakes. Their menu is filled with classics like ‘Enchiladas’, ‘Tacos’, and ‘Burritos’, alongside some less common dishes like ‘Chiles Rellenos’.

Their ‘Tacos Al Pastor’ at $14 and ‘Chicken Enchiladas’ at $15 are local favorites. Vegetarians can enjoy the ‘Vegetarian Burrito’ at $14, while vegans can opt for the ‘Vegan Tacos’ at $13.

This eatery is both vegan and vegetarian-friendly, offering a wide range of plant-based dishes.

1. The Art Factory

Topping our list is The Art Factory, a unique dining experience that combines art, culture, and fantastic food. The menu is diverse, featuring dishes from various cuisines, making it a favorite spot among locals and tourists alike.

Popular dishes include ‘Shrimp Scampi’ for $24 and ‘Steak au Poivre’ for $32. They also serve a mean ‘Veggie Stir Fry’ at $18 and a ‘Vegan Burger’ for $16.

The Art Factory is quite accommodating to vegetarian and vegan diners, making it the top spot on our list.

If you’re planning a visit to Pompton Lakes, be sure to check out these fantastic eateries. Whether you’re a meat-lover, vegetarian, or vegan, there’s something for everyone in this delightful New Jersey town. Bon Appétit!


What is the average cost for a meal at the top restaurants in Pompton Lakes, NJ?

The average cost for a meal can vary based on the restaurant and the type of meal you choose. Generally, you can expect to spend anywhere between $12 to $35 per person.

Are there any restaurants in Pompton Lakes that offer special diets such as gluten-free or keto?

While this article primarily focuses on vegan and vegetarian options, many restaurants are becoming more accommodating to various dietary needs. It’s best to check the restaurant’s website or contact them directly to inquire about gluten-free, keto, or other special diet options.

Do the top restaurants in Pompton Lakes offer take-out or delivery options?

Most restaurants nowadays offer take-out options, and some may offer delivery services. It is advisable to check the restaurant’s website or contact them directly to confirm.

Is it necessary to make a reservation at these top-rated Pompton Lakes restaurants?

Some restaurants, especially fine dining ones like Oceanos Restaurant, may require or recommend reservations. However, casual eateries like pizzerias generally do not. It’s always a good idea to check ahead if you’re planning a visit during peak dining hours or if you have a large party.

What are the operating hours of these top 10 restaurants in Pompton Lakes?

Operating hours can vary significantly between restaurants and may also change based on the day of the week. For the most accurate information, we recommend checking the restaurant’s official website or giving them a call.

Are there any child-friendly restaurants in Pompton Lakes?

Many restaurants in Pompton Lakes are family-friendly. However, the atmosphere and menu at some establishments might be more appealing to children. Pizzerias like Moneti’s and Frank’s Pizza or casual eateries like Thatcher McGhee’s might be especially popular with younger diners.


In conclusion, Pompton Lakes, New Jersey, is not just a small town with a scenic charm but also a hidden gem for food lovers. From the hearty comfort of brunch at Cyndia’s to the exotic flavors at Thai Jasmine Cuisine, the town’s culinary landscape is as diverse as it is delightful. Whether you are seeking the warmth of a family-run pizzeria, the thrill of Cajun spices at The Bayou, or the sophistication of fine dining at Oceanos Restaurant, Pompton Lakes offers a culinary journey that caters to a wide range of tastes and preferences.

Moreover, the town’s top restaurants show great consideration for vegetarian and vegan diners, ensuring that everyone has a place at the table. So, if you find yourself in Pompton Lakes, don’t miss the chance to explore these fantastic dining destinations. These ten restaurants encapsulate the spirit of this wonderful town – warm, welcoming, and full of delicious surprises.

As you embark on your culinary journey in Pompton Lakes, we hope this guide proves invaluable in finding your next favorite dining spot. After all, great food is not just about feeding the body, but also about feeding the soul. Bon Appétit!